We’re All Playing the Same Instrument

I’m sure others have done it, but Pablo de Sarasate and Niccolo Paganini are two legends (see yesterday’s greats list) who specialized in writing breathtaking compositions for the violin that highlighted their own immense capabilities with the instrument.  Many of the pieces they wrote have become well-known showpieces for violinists; these pieces, when played as their creators intended them to be played, separate the good from the great.

Being a beginner has a different flavor depending on the pursuit in question. When you are a beginner runner, for example, it seems like you’re still sort of doing the same thing that the best runners are doing.  One foot in front of the other.  Breathe.  Speed is the only real measure that differentiates.  Sure, some people flail around while running; some have absolutely no physical aptitude for it whatsoever, but most of us can get into a basic stride that works, and if you snap a photo of us running our running will be similar enough to that of the pros.  Now, I will confess to being a pretty good runner-  I’ve been doing it for close to 15 years now, but I believe my perspective on this to be sound.

Contrast that with the perspective of a beginner violinist listening to something like Mischa Elman’s Gavotte while trying to play the same piece!  It really seems as though we’re not playing the same instrument.  Perhaps the difference is that almost all humans can run.  Very few take up the violin, by comparison.  The violin is not a natural bodily activity that natural selection decided would work out well for humans over the course of hundreds of thousands of years.  Playing the violin does very little to increase the likelihood our genes will survive in the grand scheme of the universe!

But some of us hit the jackpot – like Midori Goto.  Her mature Tchaikovsky  (I saw a 2011 performance on YouTube) is one of the most brilliant I’ve seen.  Here she is in 1990 at her Carnegie Hall debut, age 19, playing one of those pieces that separates the good from the magnificent – de Sarasate’s showstopper Zapateado:

Thanks for reading.


One comment

  1. […] De Sarasate, violin virtuoso and composer, is also widely considered to be one of the greatest.  Recently, I was tickled to discover that the two have something in common […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: