When Wrong Sounds Right

To begin each lesson, Teacher asks me to play some song from some ways back, relatively speaking, in my repertoire.  I have them all memorized, of course (it’s the Suzuki Way), and I do play them all through at least once every time I practice.  When I’m practicing, I start with Twinkle Twinkle and work straight through, in order, all my songs to date.  When I do it that way, I have no difficulty recalling the songs at all, nor the sequence in which I learned them.

But Teacher calls for a title, and I’m not so good with the titles. Yesterday she said, “Let’s start with….Andantino or Allegreto; you choose!”  They are the two Suzuki-composed tunes in Book One that basically teach students to play notes in D Major.  I can’t keep them straight.  I said, “I’ll do the one that starts on D – I’ve been having trouble keeping that one in tune, for whatever reason.”  “Allegretto!” she said.

I started playing, reminding myself of the first few notes, then said, “OK, here goes.”  The song came out better, probably, than anything I’ve ever played for her.  Of course I play best when I’m all by myself – I’ve mentioned to Teacher many times the fact that I wish she could hear me when she wasn’t standing there!  But this time it came out great.

Except not quite.  Teacher corrected me on a note I’ve been leaving out.  Allegretto is one of the songs that I learned before I even had the book, one of my older songs, and somehow I memorized it wrong and have practiced it that way dozens of times!

I’m taking two lessons away – one, I don’t think that would have happened if I had been reading music the whole time.  But I can’t be sure – at some point I did have it correct – Teacher would have seen to that.  I’m just now approaching the 6 month mark of my playing, so I have very little experience with how well I will memorize songs for the long haul, and if I can expect other notes in other songs to become similarly wayward!

Lesson Two: There’s always something to improve upon.

Thanks for reading.



  1. If I had a dollar for every time a student told me “But I played it so well at home!” :). And I know I’ve said it myself over the years. Hey, I think it’s time for you to post a little audio file of “Allegrett

  2. I have been pondering if and when to reveal my playing to the world! Thanks for the encouragement!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: